Whistle Logomark Whistle Logo Burger Close Play Icon Whistle Lines 02 Speech Marks Testimonial Pattern Testimonial Pattern 02 Search Icon Down Icon Global Pattern Global Pattern Chevron Left Chevron Right

An Official Problem

By Dean Blandino


About the Author

Dean Blandino, ex Sr VP of NFL Officiating, is the current rules analyst on Fox Sports and executive director at Whistle. He’s also been named the director of instant replay for College Football Officiating.

Participation in youth sports is part of the educational process in many ways. Very few of us go on to play sports beyond high school, but the lessons learned will last a lifetime. Sportsmanship, teamwork, and how to deal with adversity are all part of the landscape. Another vital yet under- appreciated part of that landscape are game officials. Without officials there wouldn’t be any organized sports on any level. Game officials ensure games are played fairly and even more importantly safely. That is why the challenge in front of us is so critical.

The number of registered officials across most sports continues to decline. Many states have had mass cancellations and postponements of games due to the shortage. One recent study in Iowa, a place known for exceptional participation, highlights the issue. From 2007 to 2017 there was a 12 percent decrease in its total number of registered officials across the seven high school sports that require officials for postseason events (baseball, basketball, football, soccer, swimming, track and field, and wrestling).

An Official Problem Image

Even more alarming is the fact that the high school association saw 910 officials choose not to renew their registration for the 2017-18 school year and 351 of those had only signed up for the first time the previous year. The population of officials is also ageing at an alarming rate. For example, 86% of track and field officials and 70% of swimming officials in Iowa are over the age of 50. While experienced officials are a good thing, without a steady pipeline of younger officials coming into the pipeline we will have a critical mass dilemma.

Why the shortage? What are the issues we must address? Many young people have no idea that officiating can be a career path, and even if they are interested have no idea how to get started. A recent survey conducted by the National Association of Sports Officials that included roughly 14,000 game officials from across the country highlighted this issue. When asked how they got started 35% said they were approached by an official or a coach. Only 5% indicated they began because of seeing some form of advertisement. During my time at the NFL many young people reached out to me amount officiating and how they could get started. We must do a better job reaching out to our youth, especially our student athletes, introducing them to officiating and putting them on the right path.

Another challenge highlighted in the NASO survey is retention. When asked whether sportsmanship has improved or declined 57% answered that it has declined and 27% identified no change. When asked what level had the worst sportsmanship 36% responded the youth competitive level. Combining that with high school and youth recreational sports and you have where 63% of the respondents landed on the question.

So, let’s set the scene. You’re a young official working your first youth game. The kids are very respectful, and you are enjoying the experience. There is a close call and you are all over it. Your adrenaline starts pumping and you start to think that this is actually kind of fun. Then the yelling begins. It might be from a coach, or more likely a parent. It continues and with each play seems to become more intense and personal. As the yelling increases the chances of you continuing to officiate beyond this game decreases.

Unfortunately, this is an all too often occurrence. In the NASO survey, when asked who causes the most issues with sportsmanship 39% of game officials responded it was the parents compared to only 10% identifying the players. Coaches and fans came in at 29% and 18% respectively. This is the state of affairs at the youth level and one of the main reasons for the shortages across the country.

Not only must we create a more effective partnership with our schools and youth sports organizations to make sportsmanship a priority, we must provide mentorship opportunities for our young officials to ensure the retention rates do not continue to drop.

An Official Problem Image

Our mission at Whistle is to use our technology to connect officials with events across every level of sports and take on the many issues in the officiating world to create a better environment for everyone involved.

We sent just short of 6,000 questionnaires while conducting our own market survey which 67% of the assignors that responded agreed there needs to be an easier way to hire and pay game officials and 63% stated that promoting their sports program directly to game officials is often a challenge. Game officials highlighted a further disconnect with 69% stating that they would like an easier way to officiate more games and competitions in their area and/or state.

By using Whistle, game officials have a new level of access to assignors and events and can communicate with other game officials. Access to other officials will foster better relationships and provide younger officials with potential mentors along the way.

They can provide feedback about their experience at events both positive and negative, so we can reinforce the positive, and address the negative before another official has a similar experience.

There are many benefits to officiating. It is a way to give back to the community and provides a unique opportunity to positively influence young people. It helps develop interpersonal skills and sharpens one’s judgment skills. You must make instantaneous decisions, handle pressure, and resolve conflicts. It’s also a way to stay involved in sports, stay in shape, make some money, and most importantly make lifelong friendships.

Whistle will help introduce people to officiating and provide greater convenience, access, and connections so they may continue their career and enjoy all the benefits officiating has to offer.

Let’s stay in touch

Get the latest Whistle news and blogs straight to your inbox…


  • John

    Great read!

  • Rick

    Nice to hear some solutions as an umpire. No sign of the issues slowing down.

  • Steve

    Great article. Hit it on the head.

  • Kevin Gaw

    I think that the ability to reach out and to actually lead in this aspect of recruitment is lacking....in nearly all sports. Usually, when i ask players about reffing at the after match 'eat-up' [organized by some awesome parents], they defer....and i cannot follow-up...This needs to be formally spelled out to the he coaches that they need to get the kids to follow-up and get practice reffing, at practice....i have seen this model work in waterpolo, soccer baseball and rugby...just be a ref at practice...then, these first game nerves will temper and the kids that like it will pursue reffing. If exposure is the issue, force it on them. Make the kids take the 'ref test' or whatever training, as part of being on the team...yes making this a training requirement....knowing the laws does not help with the other aspects either....then kids that may be marginal in the participation can become integral to the enjoyement and allowing the match to be played, just by being the touch-judge or table crew for the JV match...whatever small bit. It all starts with small actions and with them the large pool of potential refs can be vetted and those that love it become leaders. Good luck with it.

  • Dana

    Great article. It hits on all of the issues we all face at our level.

  • Jason

    Great post! The example of the young official working their first game and then ultimately getting noise from the crowd is a perfect example of why I believe it is so hard for officials to want to continue to officiate when they are just getting started.

This Website Uses Cookies.

By using our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.